Exploring Electric Hybrid Water Heaters: Advantages and Disadvantages

Looking for an energy-efficient and cost-effective way to heat water?

Electric hybrid water heaters might be the perfect solution!

These systems work by extracting heat from the air, reducing energy consumption and lowering energy bills. Plus, they help minimize your carbon footprint, making them a sustainable option for eco-conscious homeowners.

Dive into the details: discover what hybrid water heaters are, weigh their pros and cons, and learn how to choose the best model. Compare popular models and various types to find the perfect fit for your needs.

How Electric Hybrid Water Heaters Work

Electric hybrid water heaters efficiently heat water by extracting heat from the surrounding air and transferring it to the water. This process is similar to how refrigerators or air conditioners function, but in reverse.

These systems utilize heat pump technology, incorporating components like a fan, refrigerant, condenser, evaporator coil, and compressor to apply refrigeration principles. The heat pump, located on top of the unit, draws heat from the air and raises its temperature before transferring it to the water.

As the refrigerant vaporizes, it moves to the compressor, where its temperature increases. The heated vapor then flows into the condenser coil, releasing its energy into the water through the heat exchanger and storage tank.

In addition to providing hot water, these systems cool and dehumidify the surrounding air. This added benefit helps homeowners reduce energy consumption by cooling their homes while heating water.

Main Components

Electric hybrid water heaters are similar to traditional electric models, featuring a storage tank to hold hot water and insulation to retain heat. An anode rod protects the tank from corrosion, while a drain valve at the bottom makes maintenance and flushing easier. The TPR (Temperature and Pressure Relief) valve near the top ensures safety by preventing extreme pressure and temperature buildup.

In addition to these standard features, electric hybrid models include two heating elements with thermostats for supplemental heating, especially when the heat pump operates less efficiently in colder weather.

What sets hybrid systems apart are the components inside and on top of the unit. These include a fan, compressor, evaporator, and condenser, which make the system unique.

Advanced models like those from Rheem and AO Smith feature electric circuit boards and LED control panels with touchpad buttons, allowing users to easily adjust temperature and efficiency settings.

List of compents:

1. Fan
2. Compressor
3. Evaporator
4. Condenser
5. Refrigerant
6. Insulation
7. TPR valve
8. Cold water inlet
9. Hot water outlet
10. Upper and lower thermostat
11. Drain
12. Anode rod

Types

Several types of electric heat pumps are available for purchase:

Integral type

The integral electric heat pump water heater is a single package that includes the pump connected to the storage tank and factory-installed resistance heating elements for backup heating. Installation is similar to that of a standard storage tank, except for the condensate drainage requirements.

These are also referred to as hybrid water heaters because they can switch to standard heating elements during high demand. The unit automatically switches to the “hybrid” mode, which is available on the control panel.

Add-on

An add-on water heater heat pump, or retrofit unit, is installed alongside an existing heater either on top of the tank or wall-mounted. It replaces the tank’s lower heating element and becomes the primary heat source. To circulate the water, a small pump must be installed between the tank and the pump.

Desuperheater

Geothermal heat pumps are also available and use energy from the ground to provide heating during the winter. By adding a desuperheater, a small heat exchanger, the system can also heat water.

Advantages

• Highly Energy-Efficient: Hybrid water heaters use less energy by moving heat from the air instead of generating it, making them far more efficient than traditional gas types.
• Eligibility for Tax Credits: Only electric models qualify for federal tax credits. To be eligible, the heat pump must have:
  • An energy factor of at least 2.0
  • A minimum first-hour rating of 50 GPH
  • You can save up to 30% of the total cost, or as much as $1,500, including installation and labor.
• Significant Reduction in Electric Bills: By replacing conventional electric heaters with hybrids, you can cut your electricity costs by several hundred dollars annually, thanks to their energy-efficient operation.
• Incentives Lower Initial Costs: Numerous incentives reduce the upfront purchase and installation price, making it more affordable to switch.
• Advanced Control Features: They come with precise temperature management, allowing you to easily adjust settings for optimal comfort and savings. These controls ensure your system operates at maximum efficiency.
• Wi-Fi Capability: Many models feature Wi-Fi connectivity, allowing you to remotely monitor and control your water heater from your smartphone, tablet, or computer. This added convenience helps you track energy usage and adjust settings for further savings.
• Simplified Diagnostics: They include advanced diagnostics that make troubleshooting easier, helping you address any issues quickly and reducing the need for expensive repairs.
• Longer Lifespan: Hybrids tend to last longer than traditional electric or gas types due to their efficient design and lower operating temperatures, reducing wear and tear on components.
• Environmentally Friendly: They produce fewer carbon emissions compared to gas models, making them a more eco-friendly option for homeowners who want to reduce their environmental impact.
• Quiet Operation: While heat pump systems do generate some noise, they generally operate more quietly than gas heating devices, providing a more peaceful living environment, especially in indoor installations like basements or utility rooms.
• Improved Air Quality: As part of their operation, heat pumps dehumidify the air in the room, which can help improve indoor air quality by reducing moisture levels and preventing mold growth.
• Versatility: These devices can be installed in a variety of settings, including garages, basements, and attics. Many models can operate in ambient temperatures as low as 40°F, making them suitable for a wide range of climates.
• Lower Maintenance Costs: Because they have fewer moving parts and operate efficiently, they generally require less maintenance compared to conventional gas or electric types, reducing long-term maintenance costs.

Disadvantages

• Higher Initial Cost: Hybrid water heaters typically have a higher upfront cost compared to traditional electric models, which can be a barrier for some homeowners despite long-term savings on energy bills.
• Prone to Failure: While generally reliable, hybrids can be more prone to failure than traditional electric models, especially if not properly maintained or if exposed to harsh conditions. Their complex components, such as the compressor and fan, can wear out over time.
• Cooling Effect in Cold Regions: As they extract heat from the surrounding air, they cool the room where they’re installed. This can be problematic in cold regions, where additional heating may be required to offset the cooling effect, increasing overall energy use.
• Supplemental Heat Needed in Cold Areas: In colder climates, their efficiency decreases, requiring supplemental heating to ensure consistent hot water supply. This can result in higher energy consumption during winter months.
• Requires Sufficient Air Supply: For proper operation, hybrid models need an adequate supply of air to extract heat from. Installing them in spaces with limited airflow, such as small closets, can reduce their efficiency and may lead to operational issues.
• Noise Level: Heat pumps often produce a humming or buzzing sound during operation, similar to that of an air conditioner. This noise can be disruptive, especially when the unit is installed near bedrooms or living spaces, making it less suitable for certain areas of the home.

Buying Tips and What to Look For

Electric hybrid water heaters offer more than twice the efficiency of traditional electric models. They perform best in warmer climates, where they can also cool and dehumidify the surrounding air, providing extra benefits beyond just hot water.

However, the efficiency of these systems depends on several factors, including the surrounding air temperature, incoming water temperature, heat transfer characteristics, and potential energy losses within the system.

When purchasing an electric hybrid water heater, consider the following parameters for comparison:

• Coefficient of Performance (COP): The COP measures performance by defining the ratio of heat pump energy output to electrical energy input. A higher COP indicates better performance and efficiency.
• Energy Factor (EF): The EF is the ratio of energy output to energy input. For hybrid water heaters, an average EF is around 3, while conventional electric types have a maximum EF near 1. A higher EF means more energy-efficient operation.
• First Hour Rating (FHR): The FHR indicates how much hot water the system can deliver during peak usage periods. A higher FHR suggests better performance when you need hot water most, such as during morning showers or when multiple taps are in use.
• Capacity: Consider the size of your household, the number of bathrooms, and family size when choosing the right capacity. For a household of four, a 50-gallon unit is typically sufficient, though this depends on the FHR and recovery rate. Hybrid water heaters are available in sizes ranging from 50 to 80 gallons.
• Type: While this guide focuses on stand-alone or integrated models, it’s worth noting that you can also add a heat pump to an existing electric unit.
• Efficiency: To maximize savings, look for models with the highest energy factor. These units will save you more in the long run by reducing energy consumption.
• Climate Considerations: Keep in mind that the efficiency is reduced in colder climates. During cold weather, the electric elements in the heater become the primary heat source, which can increase energy use.
• Location: Ensure the room where the unit will be installed allows for sufficient air circulation and space for servicing and maintenance. Most models require at least 1,000 cubic feet of space for proper operation. They can use either indoor or outdoor air, but sufficient airflow is crucial for optimal performance.
• Brand: Choose a model from a reputable manufacturer like Rheem, AO Smith, Bosch, or Stiebel Eltron. Always work with certified installers to ensure proper installation and avoid voiding the warranty.
• Warranty: Look for models with a strong warranty, ideally a lifetime warranty. Models with stainless steel storage tanks are particularly durable and resistant to corrosion, offering long-lasting reliability.

Installing Tips

Heat pumps don’t directly generate energy and can cool the space they operate in. Therefore, they work best in isolated areas such as garages, attics, utility rooms, basements, and spaces with a year-round average temperature between 40°F and 90°F, provided there is adequate airflow.

In colder climates, heat pumps are often installed indoors, offering both water heating and room cooling with dehumidification. However, in these regions, ice buildup on the condensing coil can restrict airflow and damage internal components, leading to expensive repairs. To prevent this, it’s recommended to choose a hybrid water heater with a “Defrost Mode.”

If your home requires high hot water demand, experiences high electricity or gas rates, or lacks a gas supply installing a hybrid model is a smart option.

How Electric Hybrid Water Heaters Compare

Analyzing Popular Models

Model/Features	Size (gal.)	Energy factor	First Hour Rating (gal.)	Warranty
American	50 66 80	3.42 3.0 2.73	66 79 84	10
AO Smith Voltex	50 66 80	3.42 3.45 3.45	66 79 84	6
Rheem	50 65 80	3.55 3.7 3.7	67 75 89	10

Other popular manufacturers/brands are AirGenerate, Stiebel Eltron Accelera 300, E Tech by AO Smith, North Road Technologies, Sanyo, Hitachi, Toshiba, and others.

Hybrids vs. Electric

• Efficiency: Hybrids are 2-3 times more efficient than traditional electric tank-type water heaters.
• Technology: Hybrids use a combination of heat pump technology and electric heating elements as a backup, while electric models rely solely on heating elements to warm the water.
• Speed: Hybrids are slower at producing heat but offer multiple operating modes, which can adjust the recovery rate and efficiency based on your needs.
• Cost: Hybrids are significantly more expensive. A 50-gallon hybrid unit can cost over $1,000, while an electric model typically costs only a few hundred dollars.
• Advancement: Hybrids are more advanced, featuring modern technologies like advanced controls and often better energy-saving capabilities.

Hybrids vs. Gas

• Efficiency: Hybrids are more efficient than gas tank-type water heaters, which typically have an efficiency rate of up to 70%. This difference can save you more money over time.
• Recovery Rate: Gas models have a higher recovery rate, meaning they heat water faster and are better for high-demand situations.
• Heating Speed: Gas models heat water quickly, making them ideal for households with frequent or high-volume hot water needs.
• Cost: Gas models are generally less expensive than hybrids, both in terms of initial purchase and installation.
• Functionality in Power Outages: Gas water heaters can continue to operate during power outages, unlike hybrids, which require electricity to function.
• Advanced Features: Hybrids use advanced electronics, with some offering Wi-Fi connectivity, large LCD displays, and at least four operating modes. These features provide enhanced comfort, flexibility, and convenience while maximizing energy savings.

Costs and Savings

The upfront costs of electric hybrids can vary depending on the brand, model, and location. On average, a hybrid unit can cost cost anywhere from $1,200 to $3,500 in 2023.

While the initial investment may be higher than that of traditional models, the long-term energy savings can offset the difference over time.

Installation costs for hybrid units also vary based on factors like location, installation complexity, and any necessary upgrades to existing plumbing or electrical systems. On average, installation costs range from $1,000 to $1,500, which is higher than for traditional tank-type water heaters.

American manufacturers of heat pumps claim their models can provide annual savings of around $428, with a potential reduction in water heating costs of up to 68%. The payback period for these systems is typically 2-3 years.

AO Smith’s Voltex hybrid model, for example, can save approximately $305 annually, cutting heating costs by up to 73%, with a payback period of 2-3 years.

In comparison, Rheem heat pumps estimate yearly energy costs of about $161 annually.

Conclusion

Electric hybrid water heaters, despite their higher initial cost, offer significant long-term savings through superior energy efficiency, making them a smart investment for homeowners looking to reduce both heating costs and their environmental impact.

In addition to energy savings, they have a longer lifespan compared to conventional tank-type models and other popular types. This makes them a more durable and sustainable option in the long run, further increasing their value.

Whether your goal is to lower costs or reduce your environmental footprint, a heat pump is an excellent choice. Their construction allows them to easily replace traditional electric models, and in many regions, they can function without the need for supplemental heating.

With substantial incentives available from utility companies or government programs, the purchase and installation of heat pumps can be more affordable than expected, sometimes even comparable to standard electric models.

When purchasing a hybrid, be sure to consider key factors like the Coefficient of Performance (COP), Energy Factor (EF), and First Hour Rating (FHR), as well as the brand and model to ensure you’re getting the best value for your needs.

FAQ